jedibuttercup: (dresden)
jedibuttercup ([personal profile] jedibuttercup) wrote2014-05-27 09:21 pm

Holy CRAP.

Ah-hah. Ah-ha-ha-ha. WHOO! Spent a quiet few hours in the cemetery, then came home, ate dinner, and finished the rest of Skin Game. And my initial reaction can be summed up as: holy crap.

The last few books have been kind of a slog - lots of transformational setup - but not many moments of awesome and fewer of cheer. And given the jacket blurbs on this one? Was kind of expecting more of the same from entry 15 in the series. Especially given how the last Denarian episodes went. And all the problematic stuff in Cold Days that made the Knight mantle even more alarming. But while there were teary and apprehensive moments in this one ... there was a lot more cackling and gasping and shrieking with glee.

And goddamn, pardon my language, but: you can really, really tell sometimes that the skeleton of this whole intricate series has been largely planned out from the beginning, because with every book it seems like more and more threads from earlier novels that seemed innocuous when first encountered suddenly pay off with a vengeance. And not just the mentioning of earlier especially relevant events, such as Death Masks and Small Favor for this one; but stuff that had me going, "oh, I had my suspicions about that four books ago, but damn!" and "hah, called it!" and "what the heck, he's been planning that for how long? Well, that puts a different spin on that scene in Dead Beat!" and so on.

There are, of course, plenty of new threads added to chew on. But the sum's a lot more energizing than otherwise, for once. And Harry's finally digging himself out of the trench of depression that, in retrospect, is probably why the last books did seem like such a slog; unreliable narrative POV at work. I see what you did there, Butcher!

Oh, and one more thing, to cap off this largely spoiler-free review (I'll have to reread and get more in detail later; it's just too much to break it down now): sometimes I suspect Butcher goes trolling trope sites for completely ridiculous-sounding ones to reclaim in kickass fashion. Because, again, damn. (Said with all the admiration in the world).

(My dad would have loved it.)

[identity profile] sulien.livejournal.com 2014-05-28 10:45 am (UTC)(link)
Woohoo! Your review here gives me more hope than I've had for the Dresden Files series since before Changes came out and I am so very grateful that you are posting it. Between what you have here and Priscellie's assurances, I'm no longer worried about being blindsided by something in the book and going into a horrible blue funk because of it and I am realy looking forward to reading Skin Game like I used to look forward to the other books. Thank you!

Oddly enough

[identity profile] anabels.livejournal.com 2014-05-28 09:11 pm (UTC)(link)
For some reason I have just started re-reading "Ghost Story" which I rather like. Was debating waiting for the price to come down before getting the new one... But I am home sick and it sounds good!

[identity profile] faithburke.livejournal.com 2014-06-01 11:45 am (UTC)(link)
I'm going to try staying spoiler-free as well, but I would just like to say YES, because for the first time since Changes I was reading it and occasionally giggling aloud, talking to the characters, etc. (Please say I'm not the only one who does that?)

I have hope for Harry Dresden again. Yay!